Montauk Proposal Celebration: Where to Go After “Yes”

Montauk Proposal Celebration Ideas You’ll Love

Planning a Montauk proposal celebration after your big “yes”? Whether you’re heading out for champagne and oysters or grabbing a morning-after jelly croissant, Montauk has the perfect spots to make your engagement weekend unforgettable.

As a local proposal photographer, I’ve helped countless grooms plan the moment—and what comes after. Here’s where my couples love to eat, drink, and toast their Montauk proposal celebration.

---

Where to Dine After Your Montauk Proposal

Duryea’s Lobster Deck
If you want that jaw-dropping sunset view while you sip rosé and feast on fresh lobster, this is your spot. The deck is iconic, the vibe is upscale but relaxed, and the photos here? Chef’s kiss.

668- The Gig Shack
For something more laid-back, head to The Gig Shack. It’s got the kind of local charm that makes you feel instantly at home, with live music, killer fish tacos, and the perfect casual vibe to keep the celebration going.

Sel Rrose Montauk
Looking for cocktails and a touch of bougie energy? Sel Rrose delivers ambiance, oysters, and just the right amount of glam to elevate your engagement night.

Scarpetta Beach at Gurney’s
Gurney’s brings the luxury if you’re turning your proposal into a weekend getaway. Scarpetta’s Italian menu, oceanfront dining, and fire pits make it feel like a mini honeymoon.

---

Start the Next Day with a Montauk Classic

Montauk Bake Shoppe
You cannot leave town without stopping here. Whether you’re celebrating your new fiancé(e) status with jelly croissants or cinnamon buns, this cozy shop is a post-proposal staple.

---

Make It a Full Montauk Proposal Celebration

Ready to Propose in Montauk?

Whether you’re here for a night or staying for a weekend, these spots will turn your proposal into a story worth telling over and over. I’ve helped grooms plan every detail—from the proposal location at Camp Hero to dinner reservations after. And yes, I can help you too.

📸 Ready to start planning? Let’s talk and create your Montauk proposal celebration from start to finish.